How Instant Replay in Baseball Will Resurrect the American Economy

Posted: October 15, 2010 in MLB, Pop Culture

In light of what has been one of the most controversial seasons for officiating in Major League Baseball, a lot of opinions have been swirling around whether or not MLB should fall in line with the rest of the professional sports and implement a review system for questionable calls. Many people don’t watch full baseball games due to the length of games and its “old school” customs. But baseball has done some things to appeal to the 21st century sports consumer while keeping its traditionalist lawn finely kept.

Baseball is still “America’s pastime” whether we like it or not and it still will be for years to come even with issues surrounding steroids, cheating, and poor umpiring. We made it past the cheating and roids for the most part and the umps are currently up to bat. The time is upon us where MLB needs to decide whether or not they are going to delve into the realm of instant replay similar to the process NFL has in place and I have a few ideas that I think would satisfy both the modern perfectionists and the stubborn traditionalists.

Baseball should implement a review system, but a limited review system at that. The Mackin Review System (MRS) will allow for fair play on the field while not hindering the already painfully slow pace of the game. My boy Mike Wilbon said it best by saying “Baseball is just like watching golf, you can watch it on a Sunday afternoon, take a nap, except when you wake up a lot has changed.”

Baseball needs to steer clear of becoming an old man’s couch and country club sport and at the same time keep those old fogies happy. If we allow for a system that reviews all matters involving homerun accuracy, on base safe/out calls, the fair/foul line, trapped catches, and hit by pitches then the game will become more correct than a naked eye, while still holding true to the human nature the game was built on.

However, this system will not get into the ball/strike arena. Every umpire makes border line calls at the home but that makes what baseball, baseball. By taking that out of the umpires hands you might as well eliminate the blue from the entire game and sit an iMac behind the dish with a camera that lets us know whether the pitch was a ball or strike in animated and morphed voice tones.

If this limited system is utilized the right way it is a win/win for both teams and fans. The teams get precise officiating and the fans get a consistently paced game without slowing the rate. Each teams would get 2 appeals per game (if needed). Since there are no timeouts really in baseball, once the appeal is used it is gone whether the call is overturned or not. It will mimic the NFL’s system in that there has to be enough indisputable evidence to overturn the call, otherwise the call on the field stands. The viewing monitors will be placed in a little photo both inside the home team’s dugout for fast and easy access.

Now, how will this implementation of MRS improve the American economy? I was hoping you’d ask me that, well if the MRS or a like modified version were picked up by Major League Baseball, discouraged fans would return back to the game they grew up playing. This would increase ticket sales, Food/Beverage sales, merchandise sales, and more media coverage to a billion dollar industry that is capable of patching up one of the many holes in our country’s current depression. Yes, depression not recession. Forget about politics, tax breaks, and government stimuli – the cure for the economy is instant replay in Major League Baseball.

Now that I have everyone on board, I would like to announce my running for the candidacy of President of the United States of America in 2012 under the new party of “Sports Nation.” Thank you all, don’t forget to vote and God Bless America.

  1. Drew Belcher says:

    I see where you’re coming from, completely. I do not think baseball is by any means, “slow”. If one believes the game is in fact, “slow” then implementing instant replay will just make it “slower.”Any pitch can change the game at any moment. One just has to be familiar with, and enjoy the concept of the game. As far as implementing an instant replay system in baseball, I’m with and against it. Do I think it will happen? No. Sometimes umpires make game blowing and history “fucking” calls. Perfect games are awarded or robbed sometimes based on misjudged calls. But that’s the beauty of the game. If we wanted perfect-every-time scripting, we’d go see a movie. Its what makes baseball, baseball. Watching a manager run out to the umpire after what the manager thinks is an “unjust” call and raise all hell. Spitting, cursing, even assaulting the umpire, until he gets thrown out. Do I sometimes wish there was an instant replay in baseball? Of course. Especially when an absurd call is made against or not in favor of my team, but that would take some of the excitement out of the game. I don’t believe baseball should absolutely avoid instant replay, I believe it should tackle the organizational problems that are leading to the poor umpiring rather than slapping an “electronic band-aid” on them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s